CR Construction (UK) Company Limited v. Barclays Bank PLC

Applicant sought injunction to restrain Issuer of performance bond from honouring demand it argued did not come from Beneficiary,

CR Construction (UK) Company Limited v. Barclays Bank PLC
[2026] EWHC 202 (TCC) [England]

Type of Lawsuit: Applicant sought interim injunction restraining Issuing Bank from honouring Beneficiary’s demand under performance bond and requiring return of counter-guarantee proceeds.

Topics: Performance Bond; Injunction; Autonomy Principle; Fraud Exception; Demand Requirements; Beneficiary Signature; Conclusive Evidence Clause; Set-off; Counter-Guarantee

Parties:
• Claimant/Applicant/Contractor – CR Construction (UK) Company Limited
• Defendant/Issuing Bank – Barclays Bank PLC
• Intervener/Beneficiary/Employer – Northern Gateway (FEC) No. 7 Limited
• Counter-Guarantor – HSBC
• Instructing Party – CR Const Grp Holdings Ltd

Underlying Transaction:
Design and construction residential and commercial units in Manchester, England.

Instrument:
Performance bond for GBP 11,702,897.30 silent as to practice rules and governing law; Counter-guarantee subject to URDG 758 and governed by Hong Kong law.

Decision:
The High Court of Justice, Business & Property Courts in Manchester, Technology and Construction Court (KBD), Davies, J., dismissed Applicant/Contractor’s application for interim injunction.

Rationale:
Injunction against Issuing Bank refused where Applicant/Contractor alleged no fraud and advanced no case against Beneficiary/Employer. Bond required “no particular form of demand,” only that notice and certificate come from Beneficiary/Employer. Read by their content and substance, they plainly did. The counter-signed certificate was conclusive as to liability and quantum, and the bond’s termination clause extended to an accepted repudiation.

Factual Summary:

In September 2021, Northern Gateway (FEC) No. 7 Limited (Beneficiary/Employer) engaged CR Construction (UK) Company Limited (Applicant/Contractor) to design and build a GBP 117 million residential development in Manchester. As the contract required, Applicant/Contractor caused Barclays Bank PLC (Issuing Bank) to issue a performance bond for GBP 11.7 million (10% of contract sum) in favour of Beneficiary/Employer. At the request of Applicant’s Hong Kong parent, CR Const Grp Holdings Ltd (Instructing Party), HSBC (Counter-Guarantor) issued a counter-guarantee to Issuing Bank subject to URDG 758. The bond expired on 17 January 2026 and the counter-guarantee on 16 February 2026.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Documentary Credit World.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.