CR Construction (UK) Company Limited v. Barclays Bank PLC
[2026] EWHC 202 (TCC) [England]
Type of Lawsuit: Applicant sought interim injunction restraining Issuing Bank from honouring Beneficiary’s demand under performance bond and requiring return of counter-guarantee proceeds.
Topics: Performance Bond; Injunction; Autonomy Principle; Fraud Exception; Demand Requirements; Beneficiary Signature; Conclusive Evidence Clause; Set-off; Counter-Guarantee
Parties:
• Claimant/Applicant/Contractor – CR Construction (UK) Company Limited
• Defendant/Issuing Bank – Barclays Bank PLC
• Intervener/Beneficiary/Employer – Northern Gateway (FEC) No. 7 Limited
• Counter-Guarantor – HSBC
• Instructing Party – CR Const Grp Holdings Ltd
Underlying Transaction:
Design and construction residential and commercial units in Manchester, England.
Instrument:
Performance bond for GBP 11,702,897.30 silent as to practice rules and governing law; Counter-guarantee subject to URDG 758 and governed by Hong Kong law.
Decision:
The High Court of Justice, Business & Property Courts in Manchester, Technology and Construction Court (KBD), Davies, J., dismissed Applicant/Contractor’s application for interim injunction.
Rationale:
Injunction against Issuing Bank refused where Applicant/Contractor alleged no fraud and advanced no case against Beneficiary/Employer. Bond required “no particular form of demand,” only that notice and certificate come from Beneficiary/Employer. Read by their content and substance, they plainly did. The counter-signed certificate was conclusive as to liability and quantum, and the bond’s termination clause extended to an accepted repudiation.
Factual Summary:
In September 2021, Northern Gateway (FEC) No. 7 Limited (Beneficiary/Employer) engaged CR Construction (UK) Company Limited (Applicant/Contractor) to design and build a GBP 117 million residential development in Manchester. As the contract required, Applicant/Contractor caused Barclays Bank PLC (Issuing Bank) to issue a performance bond for GBP 11.7 million (10% of contract sum) in favour of Beneficiary/Employer. At the request of Applicant’s Hong Kong parent, CR Const Grp Holdings Ltd (Instructing Party), HSBC (Counter-Guarantor) issued a counter-guarantee to Issuing Bank subject to URDG 758. The bond expired on 17 January 2026 and the counter-guarantee on 16 February 2026.
Read the full story
Sign up
now to read the full story and get access to all posts for
paying subscribers only.
Subscribe