Legal Principles for Granting Permanent Injunctions of Independent Guarantees

In a two-part article series, Saibo Jin examines how the 2016 PRC Independent Guarantee Provisions have been applied by Chinese courts for determining whether a permanent injunction should be granted.

Legal Principles for Granting Permanent Injunctions of Independent Guarantees

A Review of Chinese Law and Supreme Court Cases

The Supreme People’s Court's position is clear: Chinese courts cannot arbitrarily issue stop payment orders against independent guarantees.

After the PRC Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Disputes over Independent Guarantees (PRC Independent Guarantee Provisions) came into effect in 2016, Supreme People’s Court Presiding Judge Zhang Yongjian and Judge Shen Hongyu, who were responsible for drafting the Provisions, wrote an article “Correct Understanding and Application of the Judicial Interpretation of Independent Guarantees”[[1]], stating as to temporary injunctions for independent guarantees that:

“In judicial practice, the situation of arbitrary injunction of independent guarantees is more serious, which has affected the circulation of independent guarantees issued by financial institutions in China among countries. Therefore, strict regulation of temporary injunction procedures of independent guarantees is the top priority of the Regulations. … Article 16 (Payment Suspension Order) stipulates that the People's Court's ruling on injunction must include the facts preliminarily ascertained and the reasons for granting the application for injunction.
Secondly, Article 14 (Suspension of Payment) sets extremely strict conditions for the determination of injunction from the procedural point of view. Judicial interpretation strictly regulates the procedures and conditions for injunction, which not only curbs the abuse of rights by beneficiaries, but also avoids the abuse of procedures for injunction, effectively guarantees the transaction security of independent guarantees, protects the legitimate rights and interests of the parties and legitimate expectations, and safeguards the unity of procedural justice and substantive justice.”

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Documentary Credit World.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.